So, what exactly is a pronoun? "who" is subject (in some dialects also objects), "whom" is object, and this does not matter here at all. I parse this (at least in a spoke context) as similar to: Who does she think she is, playing the piano? We don't naturally say things like "That tall she is in my class" or "She playing piano is very good". Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, You've selected an incorrect answer (a good pointer is that another answer has more votes). This answer doesn't do that. She's Playing Piano is the 82nd track in the Undertale Soundtrack. Things like "tall she" and "she playing the piano" aren't coherent phrases. We already have answers which imply the phrase, This highlights the difference between "Who's. You can't have "who" as an interrogative pronoun and she as a subject pronoun together. This song seems to have been made to sound as if it was recorded live . Who is she? Can an autistic person with difficulty making eye contact survive in the workplace? I would not suggest using "who" as object for explaining why OP's sentences work. Incidentally, questions in English are especially weird when they involve the subject, so I'm not surprised to see ESL students struggling with them. Thank you for your observation. The fact that "play". How can I get a huge Saturn-like ringed moon in the sky? This is not about who/whom. I don't see any similarity between the OP's example and your Shakespeare example. It plays right before the hangout with Undyne while Papyrus and the protagonist are outside Undyne's House. With whom are they going to compete? @DavidK - You are absolutely correct about the type of instruction the teachers are looking for. That's how I read the original sentence, too - with an air of incredulity. Whom did she invite or Who did she invite? I do not think it is ungrammatical, but it is hard to follow. Who is he ruining my wedding??" This is why it should not be used even if it feels kind of OK to a non-native speaker. It may be followed by: Not an answer. The track is slower in-game. How many characters/pages could WordStar hold on a typical CP/M machine? A teacher asked me this question and I am having a hard time finding a simple way to explain it for her to share with her students. An interrogative pronoun will normally not be preceded by a noun because of the way questions are formed in English, but the expectation is that the noun being referred to will follow the pronoun quickly. It also has a slight resemblance to the song Doctor from the webcomic Homestuck. Personal pronouns don't want to be directly modified, especially in the subjective case. I`m looking for the easiest way to explain it to her because she teaches Junior High School English in Japan. Interesting viewpoint. Depending on the context of the phrase, it may be intended as discriminatory, or it may accidentally reflect a phrasing which has been used to discriminate in the past. Does a creature have to see to be affected by the Fear spell initially since it is an illusion? It fails because personal pronouns, especially in the subjective case, don't typically work that way. Context is a very strong thing in Japanese, almost everything can be omitted and context will do its work. Once you hear "who is she playing" you expect the sentence to end with something like "at tennis on Tuesday? I want to help but, it is an education itself, learning how English is taught in different countrieshow they approach it, translate it, and structure it against their own. In the sentence recommended against, there is no noun at all for either "she" or "who.". How are different terrains, defined by their angle, called in climbing? I`m looking for the easiest way to explain it to her because she teaches Junior High School English in Japan. @LorelC. Unrelated to the OP, almost certainly. It's not ambiguous at all -- it's just, @Tim The OP already knows that the "correct" solution is. A teacher asked me this question and I am having a hard time finding a simple way to explain it for her to share with her students. Mary is playing the piano. If you remove the indirect object, the question could be formed as: There is me in the sentence and thus, the answer is me. a) Who is she playing the piano with? - student +1. @ThePhoton The students wrote ungrammatical sentences. That, along with the track's filename, implies that it is indeed a track of Undyne playing her piano. Well, I'm sorry, they are sadly mistaken. Undertale - She's Playing Piano | Extended by BudderCobi published on 2018-04-24T00:02:19Z. So there's no place for another subject pronoun. Who is your friend playing the piano? next step on music theory as a guitar player. - teacher @wizzwizz4 I don't think so, though. It's grammatical. As mentioned in comments, a more common way to express this in everyday speech would be. So first of all, the confusion of the students is completely understandable because in Japanese the "pronouns" work exactly as nouns. English on the other hand is not: for example, every English clause must have a subject. Proof of the continuity axiom in the classical probability model, An inf-sup estimate for holomorphic functions. Whom is he fighting? LLPSI: "Marcus Quintum ad terram cadere uidet. Please note: Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Sentences b), d) and f) are a very formal way of asking a question and rarely heard or used in speech today but for some prescriptivists, the pronoun whom, which refers to the object of a preposition, is considered to be the only grammatically correct choice. (odd sounding) To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. If you want to know why using "she" in place of "the girl" is mistaken, see @Pedro A and @Gary Botnovcan's answers. The girl playing the piano. Can I spend multiple charges of my Blood Fury Tattoo at once? This is very odd for japanese English learners. a subject, indirect object, and direct object. Who is the person (or people) they are going to compete with? Download the chords as MIDI file for audio and score editing. The track is slower in-game. : Dm7, Em7, Am7, C7. The question is how to explain why it fails as a direct modifier. Who is that man? playing the pianois modifying the subject pronoun (she). Stack Overflow for Teams is moving to its own domain! b) With whom is she playing the piano? Print this page or download a PDF chord sheet. [John is coming to the party.] Undertale Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. "Who is" introduces a question. From the formal linguistics perspective, the intended question is constructed by starting with, Then you attach the interrogative pronoun 'who' as the subject. There is no pause indicated in their prompt, we must assume. But if someone is interested to see how "she" can fit into a grammatical sentence, see my answer below. When you make it present tense and imperfective aspect, the verb structure becomes, The subject 'who' raises to subject position and triggers agreement with 'be' to form, It's possible that your students are misunderstanding 'who' as a complementizer instead of a pronoun. Loading the chords for 'Undertale OST - She's Playing Piano Extended'. :( They have a problem. Her playing the piano. It is based on a section of the track Alphys. A point that needs to be made is that I would never expect to see this in written English, only spoken with an emphasis on "she". You're presenting the participial phrase as a parenthetical, and probably supplemental, modifier. Who is she playing the piano? Why "housing" is incorrect in this sentence? How can I find a lens locking screw if I have lost the original one? Toby FoxUNDERTALE Soundtrack Toby Fox under license to Materia CollectiveReleased on: 2015-09-15Producer. ), @Araucaria, when a question is based on a false premise, a good answer is to explain why the premise is false. Requested by: LynamroxWANT TO WATCH MORE?Undertale 10 Hour Extensions | Black Mesa Bugs \u0026 Glitches | Fallout OST Extended | Fav. It is based on a section of the track Alphys. Is there a trick for softening butter quickly? In the interrogative form, there is no **she (pronoun) because the pronoun here, the subject pronoun is "who". The students were given a picture prompt and expected to answer with. - person Replacing the pronoun with a noun (girl) ends all the ambiguities. Who (pronoun) is she (pronoun) playing the piano (modifier) denotes who really is something X which should be described later in detail. In the questionable sentence, by default "she" refers to the object, not the subject. That said, I believe that, from a teaching perspective, this is a great opportunity to insist on the differences between English pronouns and Japanese "pronouns". c) Who is she playing the piano to? The original phrase suggests to me that the piano player is in some way out of place, and the emphasis is not just on the identity of the she, but more on something less pleasant. ", while in English we need to follow the structural boilerplate which requires a verb and at least a pronoun: and here "she" is the word that carries the context inside it. The track stops once Papyrus knocks the door. That was the way I took the sentence. - man, woman, child Includes transpose, capo hints, changing speed and much more. Yeah, I can't even come up with an answer. English sentences have structures much more "solid". Who is playing the piano? VGM Playlisthttps://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSUjeNeKJtQqIUls8j_bqnLYR5a6FVFYOTWITTER: https://twitter.com/SUPERSKRAT2SECOND YOUTUBE CHANNEL: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrUo-Z5tCzuenU9xMdrSZAw/playlistsAll material in this video is the property of it's respected owner. Explain why "Who is she playing the piano?" When you are asking about identity, it is a good idea to give the category of person, Hope you get it ;), +1, I'd add that the property you are describing, and the reason this sentence is wrong is because the it has the structure of using a ditransitive verb, but there is no transitive meaning. Who is the person he is fighting against? @DavidK - Thank you :) I appreciate everyone`s responses (very much) but I was looking for a simple answer for that very reason, in the context of these students being English language learners in a foreign country. In linguistics,generativistsand otherstructuralists suggest that the Japanese language does not havepronounsas such, since, unlike pronouns in most other languages that have them, these words aresyntacticallyandmorphologically identical tonouns. I don't know if this will help your students, but here goes. ", Create sequentially evenly space instances when points increase or decrease using geometry nodes, Short story about skydiving while on a time dilation drug. It's just clever about when the wrong answer could be grammatical - if it was changed somewhat. e) Who is she playing for? Can we use an infinitive clause with no object in order to specify a purpose? If this is not strictly correct, recall that beginners are being taught here so minor nitpicks can be postponed. Who is the girl that I am pointing to right now? @PeterA.Schneider Hold on a minute, though. Who is that person playing the piano? Who is the person (or people) she is talking to? THAT'S UNDYNE'S HOUSE.YOU KNOW, THE ONE WITH THE SKELETON IN FRONT. Play along with guitar, ukulele, or piano with interactive chords and diagrams. Requested by: LynamroxWANT TO WATCH MORE?Undertale 10 Hour Extensions | Black Mesa Bugs & Glitches | Fallout OST Extended | Fav. I've learned that there is a little difference left between using 'who,' and 'whom.' In Japanese we can let context do its work by asking. Instead of simply omitting everything that can be inferred, as is done in Japanese, in English those things are replaced by pronouns. Get ready to play with count-off. Here, we have a subject, indirect object, and direct object. The pronoun "who" is a subject pronoun in the question "who is [plus verb or noun]", ergo, saying she is ungrammatical. English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. Fine, maybe. VGM PlaylistUndertale 10 Hour Extensionshttps://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSUjeNeKJtQoecn7utv_oZxRkReREyOeTBlack Mesa: Bugs \u0026 Glitcheshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sErAjECNYpw\u0026t=1sFallout 1 \u0026 2 Soundtracks Extendedhttps://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSUjeNeKJtQp1jhlcaj8fLHvwH6hmy8p7Fav. It's similar to 'that' that can be left out here: Another possibility is that the students are attempting to form, and are trying to use a null complementizer instead of 'that' which isn't allowed in English here. https://www.youtube.com/c/EluTranBugFables Make sure to check out the official soundtrack at: https://materia.to/undertaleID. - an adjective: Who is late? You can use she but the meaning will be different. Btw, it's perhaps even a common rhetorical figure for arrogantly addressing somebody in the third person: "Who is he disturbing my dinner?". - a verb: Who is coming to the party. Thus, the sentence is awkward and not highly idiomatic. "Depending on the context of the quote" We know the context: it is a statement by someone who is, My explanation is simple - there is a risk of people drawing inferences which are not intended when this construction is used by accident. Papyrus She's Playing Piano is the 82nd track in the Undertale Soundtrack. 3, 2, 1 Go! @Auracana I see. Doesn't it alone make you think this a bit strange? Who are you looking at? (very formal and rarely heard in speech) - a noun: Who is John? d) To whom is she playing the piano? [that=that person]. This song seems to have been made to sound as if it was recorded live, or was in fact recorded live. Hopefully this will help clearing things up with the students that might be thinking that she and the girl are exactly the same thing. To put it another way, @ThePhoton, we haven't seen the picture or read the prompt, but we know what. Undertale OST - She's Playing Piano Extended, The Chordify community says hi to Bad Bunny, Halloween costumes and metal are a match made in hell, How to play an E chord in three simple steps, Count off feature incoming in three, two, one. As mentioned in comments, this does not feel like a phrasing which would occur in written English. Nouns like "girl" work well with adjectives and participial phrases. To fix this question you need a preposition. ** Therefore, "Who is she playing the piano?" If one speaks the kind of English that still cares about the difference between, @DavidK I did not put a comma and that saved her brother from being the piano. I updated it after an overnight think. Who is the winner? @JeffMorrow Of course it's a pronoun, but your claim that ", This seems the only accurate answer of the bunch. I would explain it very simply: a pronoun is supposed to refer clearly to a noun, usually one that precedes the pronoun. f) For whom is she playing the piano? - your friend, their friend etc. In other words, can literally be translated as "the girl" as well. Please check out my new channel! Who are you looking at? It doesn't play nicely with things like adjectives and participial phrases. Obviously in the context asked it is accidental, but that doesn't capture potential confusion if this sort of phrase is used in conversation. Listen to she's playing the piano by Elenise Memea #np on #SoundCloud In Does he have it?, why doesn't have agree with he? Even though he did not make the song itself, Toby Fox did produce the song Savior of the Waking World, which does utilize Doctor's motif, and many other songs for Homestuck. Someone came here to help them out. The answers for the exams are quite specific. I like this answer because a sequence like "Who is this annoying idiot at the altar? The students may also be simply misunderstanding the prompt: Are they supposed to ask a question about the girl's identity, or what she's doing? Found footage movie where teens get superpowers after getting struck by lightning? As in, they are forming a phrase parallel to, I like the girl that is playing the piano (but not some other girl), which you can rephrase without the 'that is', I like the girl playing the piano (but not some other girl). ", and the question to be about who she is playing against, rather than who she is to begin with. There's no wrong premise here at all. Mobile app infrastructure being decommissioned. +1, none of the other answers have addressed that subtle context. When there isn't a useful one, we put an "it" there. So in their incorrect sentence 'who is she playing the piano' the 'who' might be intended to correspond to 'whether' in, I wonder whether she is playing the piano. It still would be a bit odd, but much clearer to say "Who is she that is playing the piano." The word the students were probably thinking of is (kanojo), which is often translated as "she", but can simply mean "the woman" (excluding the speaker and the person being spoken to). Who are they going to compete with? (formal) Other answers seem to focus on the plausible semantics of the given sentence, not on the syntax of the intended meaning. Who (pronoun) is the girl (noun) playing the piano (modifier) denotes who is XXXXX. Doja Cat - Vegas (From the Original Motion Picture Soundtrack ELVIS) (Official Video), Bad Bunny (ft. Chencho Corleone) - Me Porto Bonito (Official Video) | Un Verano Sin Ti, Bad Bunny - Tit Me Pregunt (Official Video) | Un Verano Sin Ti, Morgan Wallen Wasted On You (Official Music Video), Cole Swindell - She Had Me At Heads Carolina (Official Music Video), Glass Animals - Heat Waves (Official Video). The solution is the one provided by the OP. But in English, we need a word. How can i extract files in the directory where they're located with the find command? @barbecue: I don't understand your comment. Personal pronouns (, I would caution that in an exercise like this, the proper criterion is not merely whether you. Theoretically, there's a wh-complementizer at the very top of the correct question structure, but it has no spoken content in English. The meaning of "pronoun" is something that takes the place of a noun. Interrogative pronoun "Who", needs to take a noun, which is either the girl or the boy or whatever the object is, otherwise we wouldn't know Who really is (what). What is a good way to make an abstract board game truly alien? However, I don't believe it would be fair to mark a student wrong for using she. The pronoun "she" acts more like a complete and finished noun phrase than a simple noun. What does the 100 resistor do in this push-pull amplifier? The students are Junior High School (8th) grade students who are learning English to pass their High School exams. Now the entire clause will be heard as a substitute for a specific noun. @rexkogitans the vast majority of native speakers, British, Australians and Americans will choose to say "who". Who is he fighting? Well, @Ruakh, does it help to compare "as rare as any mistress belied with false compare" to "as good as the girl playing the piano", especially after substituting "she" for both "mistress" and "the girl"? [she is not identified at all]. would be providing two subject pronouns. The easiest way (as a non-native speaker), I can say the students should use the girl instead of the pronoun to avoid ambiguity. It only takes a minute to sign up. But, in your question, it becomes ambiguous. VGM PlaylistUndertale 10 Ho. Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been, Nice answer, but this doesn't answer the OP's question (regardless of whether they selected it or not! Site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. It would indicate the speaker's belief that the playing was inferior and not appropriate to the setting. Is there something like Retr0bright but already made and trustworthy? How would I explain, in a very simple way, why you cannot use she here? +1, though it's a bit of an oversimplification; something like "she who is playing the piano" or "she of the long hair" is grammatical but literary, whereas the OP's *"she playing the piano" is out-and-out ungrammatical. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? It has been very enlightening though to this teacher, the types of responses given. There, clearly, the subject is playing the pianoand of course for no one! It plays right before the hangout with Undyne while Papyrus and the protagonist are outside Undyne's House. rev2022.11.3.43003. Which part/aspect of it strikes you as "a similar weird usage"? To whom is she talking? I think that Barbecue and I read that sonnet's last line in the same way. Anyhow, my answer is clumsy, so downvotes are welcome and give me a comment for help! When the migration is complete, you will access your Teams at stackoverflowteams.com, and they will no longer appear in the left sidebar on stackoverflow.com. https://undertale.fandom.com/wiki/File:She%27s_Playing_Piano_music.ogg, Bird That Carries You Over A Disproportionately Small Gap, Can You Really Call This A Hotel, I Didn't Receive A Mint On My Pillow Or Anything. Chords for Undertale OST - She's Playing Piano Extended. The answers by The Photon and Gary Potnovcan explain it well, in my opinion, but I'd like to include and addendum focusing on the fact that you're teaching Japanese students. Where's the quickly following noun in "who disappeared?". Users who like Undertale - She's Playing Piano | Extended which is literally just "who? That's the easiest answer I can come up with. The answer could be *'she's playing her brother the piano.'*. (correct and most common in speech) By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. is incorrect. seems more natural than the last sentence on its own, without reference. How would you answer "Why is 2 + 2 = 5?". Who is that playing the piano? This is the only answer that actually answers the question, I believe. Horror story: only people who smoke could see some monsters. @wizzwizz4: You can say "That's the girl I saw yesterday", but I don't think you can say *"That's she I saw yesterday.". Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Is it incorrect to say "he/she is the perfect body type"? It is about using the pronoun she in the sentence. Who plays the piano? Among other weirdness, they don't trigger do-support: I think it's because a participle (such as playing the piano) can't modify a personal pronoun (such as she). UNDERTALE Extended SoundtrackComposed by Toby "Radiation" Fox.Game by Toby "Radiation" Fox.--- Appears in playlists My Jams by Kaylyn The Troodontid published on 2018-03-17T07:32:10Z she's playing the piano by Elenise Memea published on 2019-11-11T17:20:08Z. In the interrogative form, you do not use a pronoun when the identity is unknown. I am not a linguist, but I'll try: "a pronoun is a word that refers to some other noun that was mentioned before, or is about to be mentioned, or can be inferred by context". Who is she talking to? THAT'S UNDYNE'S HOUSE.YOU KNOW, THE ONE WITH THE SKELETON IN FRONT. Interrogative pronouns never have the noun they are referring to following them quickly, because the noun phrases they are referring to are represented by a. You can use she, if you pause to make the meaning clear: Without the pause, this is a kind of "garden path" sentence, because it leads you to a wrong expectation about how the sentence will end, creating a cognitive dissonance. She is my friend and a nice person. We naturally say things like "That tall girl is in my class" and "The girl playing piano is very good". According to you, the "who" in Who is the girl playing the piano" is not an interrogative pronoun? In Japanese, we don't use anything like the above definition of pronoun, context itself works already.
Gallery Opening For Example Crossword, Sociological Foundation Of Education Slideshare, Twisted Funny Crossword Clue, What Is Replication In Active Directory, Is 135 Degrees Celsius Boiling Point, Spring Boot Actuator Port, Medieval Jousting Weapon Crossword Clue, Titanic Wreck Location,